|
By Tony Cantú Contributing Writer A potential reconfiguration of city departments once Alamo Heights proceeds with plans for a new City Hall and fire station – a scenario that would have firefighters running through an alley to access their temporarily housed gear during emergency calls – has raised eyebrows among some residents. City Manager Rebecca Waldman outlined plans for the new City Hall and fire department during an Aug. 3 meeting of the Alamo Heights Neighborhood Association (AHNA). She has made similar presentations during formal meetings of the Alamo Heights City Council. But one aspect of the work – centered on a temporary metal building (TMB) to be installed on city property to house a state-of-the-art, $852,305 fire engine and related equipment – came as a surprise to residents at the meeting. Funding for the $200,000 TMB used to house the new fire engine, which is expected to be delivered later this year, was previously secured. The TMB would store the new fire engine and emergency gear while a new fire station was being built while a city-owned, two-story house at 213 Henderson, located the next block from the city complex, would serve as interim quarters for the crew, Waldman explained. “They’ll run across the alley,” Waldman said during the AHNA meeting, in response to a resident’s question. “It would be a three-year temporary arrangement,” she added, but noted the arrangement could take less time. Asked to expound on the subject, Waldman replied to a series of questions from the North San Antonio Times via e-mail. She assured firefighters’ response time would “negligibly” increase despite the added effort of traversing the alley. Asked how long a stretch of alley firefighters would cross on emergency calls before accessing their gear, Waldman responded: “I don’t know how long it is and I’m not sure that’s relevant.” But to AHNA President John Joseph – who stages the monthly community meetings since the residential group’s formation a year ago – the length of the alley is not only relevant, but at the very center of the debate, he said. Joseph cited the “seconds count” emergency services mantra emblazoned on bumper stickers to buttress his dismay over the envisioned temporary living arrangement – a concern shared by several AHNA members, he said. “I haven’t gone over there and measured the actual distance of the alley,” he said. “But I’m just very concerned if my house was on fire or if I was having a heart attack. It would distress me to think the first responders have to run through an alley to get to their fire truck.” Continuing with the “seconds count” charge, he said some AHNA members share his concern on potential the potential extra time firefighters would need in traversing the alley once the city embarks on construction. “I have one of those bumper stickers that say ‘seconds count,’” he said. “If that’s true, I wonder how many seconds are going to be lost with firefighters and EMTs (emergency medical technicians) running from Henderson across the alley to the temporary building.” To his knowledge, the AHNA meeting during which Waldman outlined the plan represented the alley route was discussed publicly, he said. In November 2007, city officials detailed a list of “facility action plan recommendations” that included suggestion of the Henderson home as temporary living quarters for firefighters, but without noting the need to use the adjacent alley as an emergency path. “I think most people don’t have any idea about it,” Joseph said of the alley aspect. “Of the people who now know about it, there is legitimate concern. I never heard one person ever mention this to City Council, and if they thinking about it, it was never discussed publicly.” Waldman said Fire Department Chief Dan Hagendorf agreed with her assessment that minimal extra time would be needed by his ranks. Hagendorf was out of town and could not be reached for comment. “The chief said that it is not uncommon for the firefighters to be in a different building than the vehicles,” she wrote in her e-mailed response to questions. “He had this situation when he was at Shavano Park. In summary, the chief is comfortable with the proximity of the firefighters to the temporary building during the different anticipated phases of the project.” Joseph said he was unconvinced: “This really gives new meaning to the term ‘Chinese fire drill,’” he said. Alamo Heights is just now in the talking stages planning for a new City Hall and fire station. A previous study determined it would be more cost-effective to rebuild on city property rather than renovate. Costs to build the new structures have been estimated in the $9 million range. |